Drive the west shore of Lake Butler today, down Lake Butler Boulevard past the big lots and the old oaks dripping moss, and it feels like money found this water first. It did not. The first people to go all in on this corner of the Butler Chain were a crowd of German freethinkers who followed a printer down from Buffalo, and the thing they built at the center of their town was not a church. It was a hall with a gym, a stage, and a bowling alley.
That hall is older than most of Central Florida’s churches. Which raises a fair question, standing on a lakefront lawn out here: who comes to raw Florida pine land in the 1880s and builds the bowling alley first?
The printer who mailed Florida to Germany
His name was Henry Hempel, and he made his living as a printer in Buffalo, New York. He had invented a little printing tool and patented it, which is a useful detail, because the man was about to run the whole state of Florida through a printing press.
Hempel came to central Florida around 1879, liked what he saw, and kept buying until by 1883 he held roughly a thousand acres between what is now Ocoee and Windermere. He named the place Gotha, after the city he was born in back in Germany. Then he did the thing a printer would do. He wrote a pamphlet.
He called it On the Back Bone of Florida, and he mailed it to cities in the north and across the ocean to Germany. It is a sales pitch and a confession at the same time. In it Hempel says plainly that he did not lay out Gotha to flip it for a profit. He meant to live there, and he wanted to be surrounded by a certain kind of neighbor: families of what he called a progressive nature, people of a social disposition, the sort who form their own opinions.
That last part is the whole story in a phrase. Hempel was a freethinker, which in the 1880s meant a specific thing: someone who trusted reason and evidence over authority and church doctrine. He was not building a congregation. He was recruiting a colony of people who thought the way he did, and he used a Florida orange grove as the bait.
And they came. German families answered the pamphlet, bought in, and spread out across the plat Hempel had drawn, a tidy grid of streets and lots laid over the pine with the lakes left open in the middle of it.
What a colony of freethinkers actually built
If church was not the center of town, something had to be. For these Germans it was the Turnverein, an old-country society built around gymnastics, music, and plain argument. In 1887 about thirty of them put up Turner Hall, and that building did the work a church steeple does somewhere else. Meetings. Dances. Musical nights. Even a bowling alley by the 1890s. It was the room where the colony became a town.
The man who held it all together was Charles Koehne, out of Oldenburg, Germany, by way of a German colony in Minnesota and a picture-framing business in Indianapolis. He bought Hempel’s store and a piece of ground on one of the lakes, ran the shop, taught the calisthenics classes at the hall, and was remembered as the patriarch of the place.
You can read the colony right off the Koehnes’ own stationery. The letterhead carries an engraved view of Gotha, groves running down to a lake full of sailboats, the villas and Turner Hall labeled along the bottom. Below it, in a careful German hand, somebody wrote out the whole family: Charles and Minna, then nine children, each name followed by the date and the day of the week they were born. These were people who kept records.
The letter that showed up sixty years later
Here is where it turns strange. The Indianapolis that Charles Koehne came out of was a hotbed of German freethinkers, and the first family of that world was named Vonnegut, as in Kurt Vonnegut, the novelist. His people ran the freethinker society and the German school in that city.
In 1945, long after Charles Koehne had died and his children had scattered, Franklin Vonnegut sat down in Indianapolis and wrote the Koehne kids a letter. He had dug up an old note among his papers, and it brought their father back to him: how Charles had taken the teenage Franklin under his wing at the Turner society, how he showed up Sunday mornings to give the young members encouragement. One German freethinking family, writing another, sixty years on, about a movement that reached from a hall in Indiana to a sand road in Orange County.
The winter that broke the bet
The oranges were supposed to pay for all of it. That was the pamphlet’s promise, a grove as an independent fortune. And for a few years the trees did fine.
Then came the winter of 1894 and 1895. The cold came down the peninsula in two blows, the first freezing the fruit and the second splitting the trees to the root, and the groves the northerners had planted around Gotha were dead wood by spring. For a colony sold on citrus, that was the floor dropping out. Some of the German families packed up and left Florida the way they had come.
The grove was the reason they were sold. The land was the reason they stayed.
What grew back
Because plenty of them did stay, and one of the people the empty, cheap, frozen-out land pulled in turned out to matter more than the oranges ever had.
His name was Henry Nehrling, a naturalist who moved out to Gotha for good around 1902 and turned a piece of his land into one of Florida’s first great tropical gardens. He trialed thousands of plants on it and became the man who made the caladium, that big painted heart-shaped leaf, into a Florida crop. People rode the train out from Orlando just to walk his grounds. The grove failed; the garden made Gotha famous for something else entirely.
The town eventually got its church too, a little Gothic one built in 1913, decades after the bowling alley. And if you want proof that Gotha stayed the kind of quiet, tree-shaded place where a person goes to spread out and be left alone, consider that the painter Bob Ross, the happy-little-trees man himself, is buried here under the real oaks.
The room was always the point
So go looking for the orange colony on the west side of the Butler Chain and you will not find it. The groves are gone, Turner Hall is gone, Hempel is a street name. What you find is Lake Butler Estates and the lanes around it: big lots, a lake at the bottom of the yard, oaks that took a century to get that tall.
The thing Hempel was actually selling was never the fruit. It was room, a piece of ground big enough that a family could land on it and build the life it wanted: a house, a grove, a store, a hall with a bowling alley in it. The oranges were just the first thing they tried putting on all that space. The space is what stayed.
And it is still what people buy out here. The grove is a memory and the colony is a historical marker, but the plain old Florida instinct underneath them, get a piece of ground with room on it and build what you need, is alive in every oversized lot on the west shore of Lake Butler.